Well, everyone agrees that the power outage in the northeast should serve as a wake-up call, but what sort of wake up call should it be? The President seems to be adapting the Administration line that was used during the California Energy Crisis (ie. the best solution is to spend a lot more money on power plants) :
- President Bush said he will order a review of why so many states were hit by a massive power blackout Thursday and said he suspects the nation’s electrical grid will have to be modernized.
. . .
Speaking to reporters at a downtown hotel during a two-day California trip, the president said the assessment would determine just what caused the problem and whether the U.S. electrical grid would need to be modernized as a result.
“I happen to think it does,” he said. “It’s a serious situation.”
Hmmm…I wonder if Bush knows anyone who could update those power plants?? Seriously though, saying the system needs to be modernized is a start. The power grid definitely needs to be updated, but just upgrading the equipment isn’t gonna do it.
The real wake-up call should be the lessons that lie below the surface of this problem. For one, this should finally disprove the myth that privatizing utilities will result in better performance. As Atrios put it :
- Well, we don’t really know what caused it yet, but let me say one thing – no pure private market system will ever exist to give private companies, absent monopolies, any incentives to invest in a sufficient, and sufficiently reliable, general transmission infrastructure.
In other words, when a complicated system as vital as power, water, public transportation, telephone lines, etc. is put in the hands of a party whose only interest is making a profit, every bit of redundancy is a hit against the bottom line.
Privatization may look great on paper, but everyone with real world experience knows otherwise. How many of you have worked at a job where the failure of one piece of machinery, the crashing of one server, or the loss of one employee would cause the entire business to come to a screeching halt? It’s pretty damn common. And when a business cares about nothing but making money, investment in redundancy and cross training almost always takes a back seat.
The greater lesson that should be learned in this whole wake-up call is the fact that there clearly is a big problem with the way the energy grid is set up. Even if we took the minimal steps of upgrading all the equipment, we’ve still got a situation in which the entire northeastern part of our country has a single point of failure. Everyone was relieved when government officials assured us that this wasn’t related to terrorism, but shouldn’t that be the real wake-up call? If all the power in New York can be wiped out with a single lightning bolt (which is the most recent theory I’ve heard about the cause of the blackout), what’s going to happen when terrorists begin their next major attack by wiping out all the power, telephone service, water, etc. with a few well-placed truck bombs?