Who won the debate?!
I hope Arianna had some flowers waiting for her this morning, because she did all the dirty work for Bustamante and McClintock. By continuously attacking Schwarzenegger, she left the other two major candidates free to discuss the issues and keep their hands clean. Here was my favorite exchange of the evening :
- Huffington: Your analysis fits perfectly the Bush administration in Washington
Schwarzenegger: If you want to campaign against Bush, go to New Hampshire. It’s the proper place for you. You’re in the wrong state right now
Huffington: The people of California need somebody who is going to fight the Bush administration for them There’s a huge connection between our budgetary problems here and the decisions made in Washington It’s completely hypocritical of Arnold (Schwarzenegger starts to interrupt.) Let me finish. Let me finish. This is completely impolite, the way you treat women. We know that
Schwarzenegger: I would just like to say that I just realized that I have a perfect part for you in “Terminator 4.”
Ahhh…a reference to Arnold’s infamous boast about shoving a woman’s head into a toilet bowl. How hilarious! With a sense of humor that sharp, Arnold should feel right at home with fellow Republicans Bill “I woulda put a bullet right between his head” O’Reilly and Ann “My only regret with Timothy McVeigh is he did not go to the New York Times Building” Coulter.
Declaring a winner in something like a debate is a little tricky. If there was a winner, I think it would be a tossup between Camejo and McClintock, since they were both able to calmly explain their positions and keep themselves out of the fighting that marked the entire debate. On the other end of the spectrum, Arnold’s performance was the kind of meaningless pandering I haven’t seen in a debate since George W. Bush in 2000. Based on this CNN poll, it looks like my views aren’t indicative of those of the general public :

Is the rest of the world smoking crack or did I just see a different debate? I suspect that Arnold set everyone’s expectations so low that his ability to form simple sentences like “You guys have an addiction problem. You should go to an addiction place.” was enough to impress people into voting for him.
The real shame is that Bustamante, who’s naturally a soft-spoken and slow speaker, has been labeled condescending and pandering. I don’t think this is necessarily the case, but if 54% of Californians think Arnold won last night’s debate, then maybe they do need to be treated like children.
2 comments
Copy link for RSS feed for comments on this post
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.


Eh, I wouldn’t go by that CNN poll. You’ve got Arnold fanboys and shitstarters voting in that. Plus, plenty of those voters don’t even live in California and Arnold is the only name they recognize.
Arianna really disappointed me last night. She was totally floundering, willing to resort to personal attacks to get attention. She seemed just as canned as she accused Arnold of being. And she repeatedly ignored specific questions about this state to attack Bush or another policy that had nothing to do with the question. Really bad performance. I remember when Laurel Erickson (or whoever it was from NBC) brought up Arianna’s tax dodging at her press conference several weeks ago, Arianna went up to her later and said, “Why are you practicing gotcha journalism?” I might ask why Arianna is practicing gotcha politics.
Also, Cruz Bustamante reminds me of Orson Welles.
Comment by Kyle — September 25, 2003 @ 1:29 pm
Of course you were watching a different debate than most Americans, especially if you think anyone from the right side of that table came out looking good. Arianna came off as petty and Cruz appeared to be a well-meaning but impotent grub, which bothers me because he really does seem to be a knowledgable figure.
Most Californians tuned in to see whether Arnold would be able to hold his own, and he did, thus winning the moral victory (like Rocky in the first movie). I’d like to give honorable mentions to Kamejo who was a one-trick pony but passionate and McClintock who really should have been declared the winner.
Comment by Earnest — September 26, 2003 @ 9:10 am