Well-Orchestrated Chaos

By now you’re all painfully aware of the sights from the protests of some of Terri Schiavo’s self-appointed defenders. There’s the bloody sheet borrowed from an anti-war rally…




…the kid whose asshole parents got him arrested…



…the standard “I own a big-ass crucifix, so Jesus likes me better” guys…



…and the woman using her first amendment rights to complain about her lack of first amendment rights.



We’ve been seeing this crap all week, but this report from one of CNN’s correspondents outside the hospice really puts all of this political theater in perspective :
DARYN KAGAN, CNN ANCHOR: Getting back to the Terri Schiavo story. Protesters are gathering outside of Terri Schiavo’s hospice in Pinellas Park, Florida. Bob Franken is live there with the very latest — Bob.

BOB FRANKEN, CNN CORRESPONDENT: And Daryn, this is probably one of most choreographed protests you will ever see. This is something that has been planed and negotiated between the police and those who are going to protest. What we can expect is a small group from among those who have been holding a vigil here in support of connecting the tube of — the nutrition tube of Terri Schiavo — are going to try and bring water in. Now, this has been done by various individuals and once they get on the property, the hospice — the people who own the hospice here do not want them on the property and they have been arrested for trespassing. And we expect that to happen today.

Now, all of this has occurred with leaders of the group having extensive negotiations with the police to discuss the parameters. One of the things that we can expect is a brief demonstration. And let’s not forget much of this is for the news cameras. And then they will be handcuffed, those who disobey the order to leave the property, handcuffed. And they do it in a certain way, they have decided, so they don’t cause too much discomfort. They, the police. They handcuff them with metal handcuffs, but double ones. In other words, they link two together. That way they’re not pulling so much on the arms of those who they arrest.
[. . .]
And to make sure you understand that this is not exactly considered some sort of high tension confrontation, the police are just in their normal uniforms, no sort of protective gear. They’ve gone through this the last couple of days with people and it’s very polite. The man who is going to be meeting the demonstrators is the person who runs the detail here, and that Lieutenant Kevin Riley (ph), who is somebody who is very adept at keeping things low-key.
[. . .]
FRANKEN: OK, what we have here now, Daryn, is that today some of the people planning to bring the water, are holding styrofoam cups with water. That is their intention, their announced intention, to try and take that water to Terri Schiavo, who has had her nutrition tube removed as of last Friday. Which, of course, means in the medical term, that she is not being hydrated. That is to say, not only is she not been given any nutrition, but has not been given any water.

What will happen, and everybody knows this, is that the police will ask them to leave. They will not leave, they will stay a foot or so on the property. The facility here has insisted that nobody can get on the property. And that’s sort of a line of demarcation. The police will ask them once or try twice to depart, and when they do not, and when they do not, they will be arrested, something they all expect to have happen.

Man, they really put the obedience back in civil disobedience, huh? Choreographed dissent really takes all the fun out of breaking the law.


posted by greg on March 25, 2005 @ 3:33 pm

9 comments

  1. I’m surprised that nobody has mentioned the parents that drove all the way from Louisiana with their ‘trophy’ 13 year old daughter that’s in a PSV with a feeding tube in a stroller complete with toys to make a point that even though she’s in a PSV, she’s still alive. What kind of perversion is that? It’s been on the news a couple of times but I don’t see anyone expressing any kind of reaction. This was one of the most disturbing images I’ve seen during this entire fiasco.

    Comment by Bernie in NJ — March 25, 2005 @ 5:18 pm

  2. They have a hard time of it, for sure. St. Augustine taught the importance of obeying earthly authorities, even if they are ungodly, because civil peace provides opportunities to spread the gospel. These people believe real revolt, real “civil disobediance,” is satanic, anti-Christian, anarchistic and dangerous. Which is to say, they see this disobediance as a distasteful duty, as a show they put on for the ignorant masses of non-christians. In this way they are a lot like their neo-con leaders.
    Frankly, I’m glad they are dedicated to symbolic protest. The last thing we need is a bunch of fanatical tissue-protectors running around killing people and blowing up county health departments.

    Comment by Joe — March 26, 2005 @ 12:02 am

  3. I wouldn’t take my eye off them yet.

    Don’t forget, it was St. Augustine who endorsed the torture of Jews for the salvation of their immortal souls.

    Comment by Stephen — March 28, 2005 @ 7:11 am

  4. my high school drama teacher must be very proud.

    Comment by cali_ — March 28, 2005 @ 8:58 am

  5. Don’t these people realize that pouring water in the mouth of someone on a feeding tube that can’t swallow will make them, well, drown?

    Comment by Paul — March 28, 2005 @ 9:15 am

  6. What I’m surprised that I haven’t heard is this:

    Terri Schaivo is a sinner! Bulimia is nothing more than marriage of Gluttony and Vanity. God called her home that day when she had a heart attack, but had mercy for the rest of us. He allowed her to be revived and fed through a tube, so that all of us could see the punishment that awaits bulimics in Hell. Bulimics, Repent!

    Comment by Dave — March 28, 2005 @ 1:57 pm

  7. Please don’t waste any more of your valuable blog space on this. The real shit is going on elsewhere. Look at the credit card bill or ANWR. This is Michael Jackson’s molesting OJ’s boobs at halftime. That is, not really news.

    Comment by Reality Bites — March 28, 2005 @ 3:41 pm

  8. Mr Reality Bites, you’re half right. This is a crappy local news story that has ballooned into a real news story now that Congress has gotten involved. Stupid or not, we have to watch and comment on what’s going on, because the people who govern us and the people who voted for them are watching and commenting as well.

    Comment by dAnimal — March 29, 2005 @ 1:13 pm

  9. It’s not the story that’s at issue, but the decision by the right to frame it as a moral crusade.
    I’m glad it backfired on them.

    Comment by Bobsled — March 30, 2005 @ 9:41 am

Copy link for RSS feed for comments on this post

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.