A New Spin On An Old Crusade

With only two days left to milk the “War on Christmas” blogging season, let me just make a point that I’ve been hinting at in previous posts and just wanna get off my chest. This whole Fox News-led crusade against liberal strawmen is embarrasing to watch, but it’s also a part of a much bigger problem. It’s a pretty well-known bit of trivia that the United States is one of the most religious countries in the Western world, but it seems to me that this all depends on how broadly you define “religious” and whether American’s willingness to describe themselves as religious actually translates into serious religious devotion. So while I’m a little unsure about America’s piety, there’s one thing that seems obvious to me : America is fraught with religious insecurity.

At least, that seems to be the thread that ties so many religiously-fueled controversies together. Putting the Ten Commandments in court houses, “intelligent” design in public schools, “under God” in the Pledge of Allegiance, and this absurd war against anyone who says “Happy Holidays” are really just facets of the same issue if you think about it. For a paranoid minority of Americans, it’s not enough to live in a country that values religious freedom, they want secular aspects of our society to reflect their religious views.

The truly remarkable thing about it, however, is how they’ve found a way to be on the offsensive while convincing the American public that they’re playing defense. Yeah, having an irrational persecution complex helps, but it’s also damn good politics. Religious activists around this country are actively trying to make changes throughout our society, yet their rhetoric (which always seems to be taken at face value) is that they’re somehow “preserving” some phantom aspects of our culture that have only existed in their faulty memories.

But if you really think it through, this modern crusade isn’t just something to get pissed off about. It’s sorta funny and sad. If we take them at face value and cede the point that our religious society is in danger of crumbling, then their tactics for reversing this trend are woefully pathetic. How do they propose returning America to her righteous Christian greatness? Having children mindlessly recite the words “under God” every morning? Making sure department stores use the word “Christmas”? Pathetic.

Is your faith so fragile that it’s in danger of crumbling in the face of mild secularism? Are tolerance and diversity interfering in the relationship between you and your lord? If the only thing stopping your religious worldview from gaining acceptance is a few radical judges who stopped you from displaying a giant chunk of granite emblazoned with an ancient list of rules you probably can’t even recite from memory, is there a chance that maybe your beliefs aren’t as strong as you’d have us all believe?

So if you find yourself in the company of those who are fighting to garnish our country with tiny bits of Jesus, please do us all a favor. Stop making us the targets of your insecurity and weakness. If your views aren’t strong enough to withstand engaging with a secular society, perhaps it’s time for a little self-reflection. If you need to see the words “In God We Trust” written on money, then you’re just fighting a losing battle with your own self-doubt. It’s one thing to battle your own demons in the public square, but I’m tired of being made the boogey man. Your spiritual weakness is not my fault.

Besides, if you’re truly sincere in your beliefs, there are much better ways to proselytize than expending so much energy on unimportant crap. For example, you could try engaging people in coversations about your religion and explain why you believe the way you do. It worked for Jesus.


posted by greg on December 23, 2005 @ 9:40 pm

9 comments

  1. Great piece. I’m so sick of hearing the Christian Right play the victim card.

    Comment by jimmarquis — December 24, 2005 @ 9:44 am

  2. Outstanding post. Really well done.

    Comment by Dilapidus — December 24, 2005 @ 10:00 am

  3. Remember, these are the same guys who are so insecure about their sexuality that they buy books on how to keep their sons from turning gay. And who are so insecure about — well, I’m not sure if it’s their wieners or their collective lack of a tan — that they invent an entire racist-sexist mythology that assumes black men and white women have some abiding desire for one another than can be properly impeded only by anti-miscegenation laws and lynchings.

    In short, whenever you see violent assholes, you are probably looking at deep insecurities. And yes, they are comical and sad, so long as they aren’t swinging right at you.

    Comment by hedgehog — December 25, 2005 @ 1:04 am

  4. Very well written and logical.

    hedgehog, you hit the nail on the head. A feeling of insecurity displays itself through an attitude of superiority, and typically leads to violent tendencies. Whereas a person who is secure in his/her self and beliefs can express opinions in a calm and rational manner, especially without attacking the opponent.

    To all those trying to “save” christmas: Let a person do as he wishes, but get the holiday right. Is christmas a baby jesus who has come according to the prophets, or a fat guy in a suit? Is that what you’re fighting for? A confused religion?

    Comment by Mr.Younger — December 25, 2005 @ 10:47 pm

  5. Reinhold Niebuhr, the 20th century theologian, said, “Frantic orthodoxy is never rooted in faith but in doubt. It is when we are not sure that we are doubly sure. Fundamentalism is, therefore, inevitable in an age which has destroyed so many certainties by which faith once expressed itself and upon which it relied.”

    In other words, the less sure one is, the more certain one must appear.

    Seen any of that lately from the far right camp?

    Good work, Greg.

    Comment by Stan — December 26, 2005 @ 9:28 pm

  6. Well, now that Christmas has passed, I can only imagine they’ll start focusing back on school prayer or any other forced religious activity.

    Either they’re insecure people or they’re the type of people to insist on “Merry Christmas” and prayer before football games but won’t lift a finger to help or do the right thing when the time arises.

    Comment by ChrisV82 — December 26, 2005 @ 11:41 pm

  7. Perfect.

    Although, now they’ll go back to focusing on same-sex marriage — the last, best liberal straw man.

    Comment by CLD — December 27, 2005 @ 7:15 am

  8. A-fuckin’-men.

    Comment by Patty — December 27, 2005 @ 10:34 am

  9. I’ve been thinking for a while how really frightened many Christians seem to be. Parents and Churches are so lame at convincing their children of the “good news” that they need schools and the government to do it for them.

    Comment by Becky — December 27, 2005 @ 5:53 pm

Copy link for RSS feed for comments on this post

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.