Media Narratives

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, John McCain is a phony. Of course, getting the public to see through McCain’s carefully-constructed persona is difficult when the media is so complicit in enforcing the view that he’s a no-nonsense, straight-talking tough guy who’s willing to reach across the aisle to do the right thing. Or as the “journalists” at CNN like to put it….

John King :

“McCain’s maverick streak doesn’t sit well with many colleagues.”

Bill Hemmer :

“The story of his life is a profile in courage, both political and personal. Before John McCain was a maverick senator, he was a Vietnam prisoner of war for six years in Hanoi.”

John King :

” Senator McCain known as a maverick, known as someone to challenge his party…he is now going back to the United States Senate, where he won the maverick label, the maverick reputation because his own party’s leadership back in the Senate is very much opposed to the very things John McCain stands for.

Kate Snow :
“Senator McCain known as a maverick here on Capitol Hill.”

Larry King :

“Tonight, personal revelations from a congressional maverick and an American hero. Senator McCain”

Candy Crowley :
“John McCain, the scrappy maverick who has defied his party and the odds”

Joe Johns :
“John McCain, the maverick conservative who has no problem crossing his party and his president when he thinks he’s right. ”

Anderson Cooper :

“John McCain, the Senator from Arizona, is a maverick, but a maverick with a following.”

Jeff Greenfield :

“John McCain is not a moderate, he’s a maverick.”
Candy Crowley :

“John McCain, a conservative, but a maverick conservative”

Carlos Watson :

“[O]n issues like homeland security you may see people like John McCain, the maverick senator from Arizona, be kind of a big champion”

Anderson Cooper :

“He, of course, a staunch supporter of the war in Iraq, also known for being a maverick within his own party. ”

Stephen Frazier :

“Interesting, now, how significant he will become, since he is a moderate and a maverick Republican.”

Suzanne Malveaux :

“Now, a familiar face that you’re also going to see on the trail is senator — this is Senator John McCain. He, of course, the maverick Republican trying to generate a lot of support there.”

Chris Black :

“Then there is the X factor, the maverick Republican John McCain determined to change the rules on political money as soon as next Monday in defiance of his own leaders.”

Kelly Wallace :

“A well-known getting the most votes within the Kerry campaign is Republican Senator John McCain. The Arizona maverick would generate tremendous excitement and help attract Republican and independent voters”

Wolf Blitzer :

“McCain is not campaigning there. For the maverick senator, the real challenge…”

Bill Schneider :

“John McCain managed to have it both ways — a principled maverick who remained Bush-friendly and kept lines open to conservatives.”

Lou Waters :

“In Washington, fellow Senate maverick John McCain angrily warned the Republican Party to, in his words, ‘grow up and learn to disagree without resorting to personal threats.’”

Wolf Blitzer :

“Eyebrows have been raised by a planned weekend meeting at the Arizona ranch of maverick Republican Senator John McCain.”

Suzanne Malveaux :

“It’s one of the main reasons why they picked Senator McCain to be a part of it, because you know he’s a critic, he’s a maverick, he’ll say what he wants to say.”

Joe Johns :

“Now, McCain, John McCain of Arizona, a key Republican here on Capitol
Hill, obviously a maverick Republican as well…”

Judy Woodruff :

“Senator John McCain is blasting what he calls crony capitalism. Up next: excerpts from McCain’s latest campaign against the system. Is he trying to sound like Teddy Roosevelt? Another political maverick is back in the spotlight…”

…and my favorite :

Howard Kurtz :

“Did the press pump up the story that the Arizona senator might — might — leave the GOP? Were journalists blatantly used by McCain advisers or can they simply not resist writing about their favorite maverick senator?”

Even when they’re questioning McCain, they can’t help but point out how tough he is. Of course, if McCain was an actual “maverick” he wouldn’t have waited until after an election year to talk tough on torture. I guess in media-land, “maverick” is defined as the first Republican to jump on a Democratic bandwagon. Nevermind what liberals say, the media likes to save their praise until McCain’s pollsters tells him to “reach across the aisle”. Blech.


posted by greg on February 20, 2006 @ 7:21 pm

8 comments

  1. Well, I think you have to remember the standards currently being set by Republican senators. Given their utter political cowardice on challenging Bush about any aspect of his conduct, even the mild criticism McCain has delivered has set him well apart from most of his own party.

    Or, “It’s easy to be above average when the average is so low.”

    Comment by John Seavey — February 21, 2006 @ 3:51 am

  2. very nice job of collecting McCain-as-Maverick labels – and every one of the labelers is on salary with the Media Machine

    Comment by Llieutenant Breakfast — February 21, 2006 @ 7:40 am

  3. John Seavey makes a very good point in his comment above – though I’m still trying to figure out what point you’re trying to make.

    McCain not critical enough of Bush/GOP? Suspicions about the timing of his criticism? No Democrats being called “mavericks” by the media talking heads?

    Perhaps you’d have Mr. McCain to pull a “Zell” and go ape-shit on Bush/GOP…that would be real responsible (and effective).

    I think Mr. McCain should be applauded for his crticisms of the policies of his own party/president. Name one leading Democrat that’s done the same.

    Comment by Martin — February 21, 2006 @ 8:39 am

  4. John Mcain is nothing more than a crossing gaurd for the same monied interest that love the free ride they’re getting from Bush.

    Comment by Kamachanda — February 21, 2006 @ 2:23 pm

  5. Out here in the frozen wilds of Wyoming, nieth the shadow of Ole Brokeback, where we’re all somehow related to Deadeye, a Maverick is a calf, seemingly belonging to no one, as in ” fire up that runnin’iron, Ed while I through a rope on this MAVERICK. Whoopee ky yai yo git along little doggie you know that Wyoming will be your new home.” Senator McCain is none of the above. He has proven ambitions for The Presidency and will seriously need that Democrat’s vote. Sadly (for the Taxpayer) it’s politics and business as usual. Even his anti-torture addendem to the Defence Budget changed nothing. Sad fact of war, sad fact of life. I suppose we are getting our money’s worth.
    Mike Meter, menber- Voter Initiative Political Party of Wyoming, where we believe that you the TAXPAYER should have TOTAL CONTROL of how much comes out of your pocket to support YOUR GOVERNMENT, and a final say-so, go or no go vote on YOUR BUDGET. AFTER ALL, NO MATTER WHAT HAPPENS, YOU’LL PAY FOR IT.

    Comment by Mike Meyer — February 21, 2006 @ 7:36 pm

  6. very nice job!

    Comment by Slav — February 22, 2006 @ 1:41 am

  7. What strikes me about this is A) how fucking lazy the press can be when describing people, and B) how hopelessly stuck they seem to be on overly simplistic caricatures of public figures. It’s like they can’t discuss anyone without reducing him or her to the emotional depth of a character in a Jerry Bruckheimer movie. I don’t wonder why our discourse has slid as far downhill as it has when I hear shit like this masquerading as news.

    Comment by briantologist — February 22, 2006 @ 1:18 pm

  8. The “center” isn’t the place for the Fourth Estate

    The media in the US has taken a beating by the right for being lanted “liberal” and a beating from the left for being slanted “conservative”. Which means they’re somewhere in the middle. Is being biased to the middle a negative? Not if you’re one of th…

    Trackback by Preemptive Karma — March 3, 2006 @ 7:26 am

Copy link for RSS feed for comments on this post

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.